Best Bagels on Long Island!
Long Island, New York is known for its bagels! The classic “bacon, egg and cheese” has become a Sunday morning ritual that Long Islanders could never imagine abandoning. Whether you enjoy a classic cream cheese and lox bagel, or a basic, plain bagel with butter, everyone loves a fresh, warm Long Island bagel! We’ve compiled a list of the so-called “best bagels on Long Island”, so you can decide for yourself, which bagel shop takes the cake!
- Bagel Boss, 1352 Peninsula Blvd., Hewlett, New York 11557
- Bagel Boss has over 50 years of experience and it shows! They have continuously used only the freshest and highest quality ingredients, to please their beloved customers.
- Better on a Bagel, 275 NY25-A, Miller Place, New York 11764
- Made from scratch every morning to ensure the highest quality, for over 1o years, Better on a Bagel has been serving the community with fresh-baked bagels, different gourmet cream cheeses, sandwiches, and specialty coffees and teas.
- Bagel Biz, 443 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville, New York 11747
- From the very beginning in 1986, Bagel Biz has provided only the most freshly baked bagels with in-house, homemade cream cheese. You can even order their bagels and have them shipped nationwide!
- The Better Bagel, 45 Merrick Rd, Amityville, New York 11701
- For over 25 years, The Better Bagel has been serving Amityville and neighboring communities their authentic, New York style bagels, hand-rolled and baked daily.
- Strathmore Bagels of East Setauket, 4088 Nesconset HWY, East Setauket, New York 11733
- Located right on the cusp of Port Jefferson Station and East Setauket, Strathmore Bagels offers amazing, fresh-baked bagels, perfectly crisp on the outside, yet soft and chewy on the inside.
- Signature Bagels, 779 Old Country Rd, Riverhead, New York 11901
- Signature Bagels deli offers a full menu of delicious breakfast and lunch items!
- Hand Rolled Bagels, 930 Hillside Ave, New Hyde Park, New York 11040
- Founded in 1997, Hand Rolled Bagels has been serving some of the best, fresh bagels in all of New Hyde Park!
- First Class Bagels, 1976 Deer Park Ave, Deer Park, New York 11729
- First Class Bagels offers hand-rolled, kettled, in-house baked bagels, every single day!
Once you find the perfect bagel, you may be interested in purchasing or leasing a brand new BMW model, like the 2019 BMW X1 or the 2019 BMW 3 Series! Stop into our Competition BMW of Smithtown Showroom at 599 Middle Country Rd, St James, New York 11780, to see a model in person. Whether you are interested in a new vehicle or a pre-owned vehicle, our experienced team can help you find the perfect vehicle for you! Contact us at 631-265-2208 to learn more about our vehicle specials or to speak with a Sales Consultant!